I have been reading a 2020 book by Matt Ridley titled How Innovation Works and Why It Flourishes in Freedom. Chapter 5 is about Low-Technology Innovation. Starting on page 170 there is a section titled Was wheeled baggage late? which says:
“Having lugged heavy bags through train stations and airports in my youth, I regard the wheeled suitcase as one of the pinnacles of civilization. But for something so low tech, it turned up surprisingly late, after the first human beings had landed on the moon. What was to stop someone inventing the wheeled suitcase in the 1960s? Why was it so late in arriving? The wheeled bag seems to be a good example of tardy innovation that should have happened sooner. Or does it?
One day in 1970, Bernard Sadow, a senior executive of a baggage-making company in Massachusetts, went on a holiday in Aruba with his family. On the way back, at American customs, he joined a queue, periodically picking up two heavy bags as he shuffled forward. Just then an airport worker strode past with a piece of heavy machinery on a wheeled trolley. ‘You know, that’s what we need for luggage,’ Sadlow said to his wife. He went home, took four castors off a wardrobe and screwed them on to a suitcase. He then attached a leash to the case and dragged it effortlessly around the house. He applied for a patent on rolling luggage, which was granted in 1972. In the application he wrote: ‘The luggage actually glides. Further, substantially any person, regardless of size, strength or age, can easily pull the luggage along without effort or strain.’
But when Sadow took his crude prototype to retailers, one by one they turned him down. The objections were many and varied. Why add the weight of wheels to a suitcase when you could put it on a baggage trolley or hand it to a porter? Why add to the cost? For several years he got nowhere, till eventually Macy’s, the department store, commissioned a line of ‘bags that glide’ from Sadow and the world gradually followed suit.
A glance through the history of patents reveals that Mr Sadow was not the first to try. Arthur Browning had filed a patent on wheeled luggage the year before Sadow, in 1969. Grace and Malcolm McIntyre had tried in 1949. Clarence Norlin had patented suitcases with retractable wheels, the better to fit into spaces, in 1947. Barnett Book filed a patent for a wheeled suitcase in 1945. And Saviour Mastrontonio had patented a ‘Luggage Carrier’ that could be used to roll ‘a bag, satchel, suitcase or the like’ in 1925. In the accompanying illustration, a carpet bag rolls in front of a glamorous lady in a stripy dress, propelled by a stiff, long handle.
Clearly, the problem was not a lack of inspiration. Instead, what seems to have stopped wheeled suitcases from catching on was mainly the architecture of stations and airports. Porters were numerous and willing, especially for executives. Platforms and concourses were short and close to drop-off points where cars could drive right up. Staircases abounded. Airports were small. More men than women travelled, and they worried about not seeming strong enough to lift bags. Wheels were heavy, easily broken and apparently with a mind of their own. The reluctant suitcase manufacturer may have been slow to catch on, but they were not at all wrong. The rapid expansion of travel in the 1970s and the increasing distance that passengers had to walk created a tipping point when wheeled suitcases came into their own.
A decade later, Sadow’s design was displaced by a superior innovation – the Rollaboard. This was the brainchild of Robert Plath, a pilot with Northwest Airlines. In 1987 he went into his workshop at home and fixed two wheels to one side of the short end of a rectangular suitcase, rather than four to the base of the long side, as Sadow had done. A case could now be titlted and dragged semi-upright with the help of a telescopic handle. Plath sold a few to fellow pilots, but ordinary passengers began to notice them and ask about how to get them, so Plath left the airline and set up Travelpro, which rapidly became a successful business. Four-wheeled versions followed, as well as new aluminum and plastic lightweight versions, and wheels that can roll in any direction so you cold push as well as pull. Innovation continues to transform the experience of travel.
The lesson of wheeled luggage is that you often cannot innovate before the world is ready. And that when the world is ready, the idea will already be out there, waiting to be employed: in America, at least. Nothing like this happened in Communist Russia or Mao’s China.”
But there is an article by Marcia Wendorf at Interesting Engineering on February 18, 2020 titled Who Actually Invented the Wheeled Suitcase? that shows a wheeled suitcase from 1954 by Yugoslav inventor Alfred Joseph Krupa.
Even earlier there is another article at Winnetka History titled Before Her Time: Anita Willets-Burnham’s Rolling Suitcase [1928]. And the Wikipedia article about her says:
“She may have been the inventor of the first wheeled suitcase. ‘Why be a human truck horse?’ Willets-Burnham asked before the Burnham’s 1928 trip, sparking her ‘grand idea.’ ‘Wheels! Suitcase on Wheels!’ she wrote in her book ‘Round the World on a Penny, her illustrated travelogue originally published in 1933. Her suitcase was fashioned by her son Bud with two wheels from an old baby carriage on one end and a telescoping wooden handle on the other.”
And there also is an adapter called a Portable Porter which straps onto a suitcase to add a pair of wheels. It is described in an article at Medium: The Portable Porter Co. on November 28, 2022 titled Why does history state we put a man on the moon before we put a suitcase on wheels? It was in U. S. patent 2,509,575 on May 30, 1950. As shown above in my colorized images, an angle plate with wheels goes on one end and the grip loop goes on the other.
An image of rolling suitcases at Saks came from Wikimedia Commons.











