I read
an article by Rose Eveleth on June 5, 2018 at
Motherboard
titled
Dear conference organizers: you’re doing chairs wrong and subtitled
Nearly
every femme-identifying person I know, myself included, has wrestled with tall
bar stools, director’s chairs, and the dreaded microphone dance. The
image of a
panel discussion from 2016 for the film
High on Crack Street shown above
illustrates her problem. Directors chairs placed near the front of a stage are
fine for men, but only work for women in slacks or in
dresses that are almost ankle length
(Amish-friendly or FLDS-friendly). Rose described having worn a knee-length
dress and then being very uncomfortable sitting on a tall stool. Later in her
article she quoted Trevor Knoblich of the
Online News Association who said:
“We
want our presenters focused on those important aspects,” Knoblich said. “They
shouldn't have to worry that their clothes match the furniture fabric, or that
their presentation is becoming an inadvertent sequel to Basic Instinct.”
You can find the exhibitionist scene from that movie he alluded to in
a 35-second
video clip at
The Sun that is definitely NOT suitable for work. Having your clothes accidentally
match the furniture or background is a another problem I
blogged about in a
September 12, 2016 post titled
Dress for success, not like a ninja.
An older, more modest setup seats the panel behind tables
with skirting or tablecloths, as is shown above in an
image from a 1982
ComicCon. Who recommends the other setup without tables, and why?
An article on May 23, 2013 by
Brad Phillips at
Mr. Media Training titled
Six ways to electrify your next
panel discussion did. His third and fourth points were:
“3. Remove The Table: The majority of panel
discussions are conducted from behind a long table. Get rid of it. The table is
a physical barrier that separates the panelists from the audience. Worse, it
diminishes the speakers’ natural body language. Just try gesturing
enthusiastically while seated in a hunched-over position at your desk, your
elbows attached to the surface. Pretty hard, no?
4. Use Stools or Chairs Instead: I often
encourage clients to position stools or chairs at the front of the stage. That
set up conveys a more casual and inviting “living room” feeling—which is the
reason all of the morning news show use it. This format allows you to use
wireless microphones instead of table microphones.”
Rose’s article also mentioned doing ‘the microphone dance’ –
about those wireless lapel microphones, with a cable leading to a transmitter (and
battery pack) meant to fit on a men’s belt or a skirt, but not on a dress.
Kristin Arnold was president of the
National Speakers
Association in 2010-2011, and in 2013 wrote a 38-page book titled
Powerful
Panels. There is a blog associated for that book, with
a post on March 26, 2014
titled
Get rid of the white, draped table at panel discussions,
and one on April
5, 2014 titled
In search of the perfect chair for panel discussions – in which
she says:
“I
like a tall, well-made, and sturdy director chair. They add an element of
informality and conversational tone to the room. The shape of the chair almost
forces the panelists to sit forward and be engaged. And, there is a place for
your feet.”
Kristin also wrote
an article in the April 2015 issue of
Toastmaster magazine titled
How to moderate a panel discussion in which she again
said:
“….You
don’t have to settle for the typical long, draped table. Why not spice it up
using a popular television-talk-show format?”
Both the skirt-length and microphone issues are mentioned in
a better
five-page article dated August 2017 from
The Urban Institute and titled
Best
Practices for Moderators. If in doubt, women should bring back-up slacks.